Fall Pumpkin Cheese Pairing | Gourmet Fall Cheese Gift | DLM | Dorothy Lane Market
DLM Mail Order Online Exclusive | $5 OFF Every $50 Spent with Code HOLIDAY2026 |

A TASTE OF DLM

Search Dorothy Lane Market

Try a DLM favorite

    Thanksgiving Cheese Pairing

    Loading image...

    Online Exclusive

    Thanksgiving Cheese Pairing

    $36.99 $44.00

    1 Goat Cheese Pairing

    The Flavors of the Season

    Bring the best flavors of fall to your cheese board. This irresistible pumpkin spice cheese pairing combines creamy pumpkin goat cheese, pumpkin spice Wensleydale, sweet oat crackers, and rich DLM Pumpkin Butter for an easy, delicious fall appetizer or entertaining spread.

    • Two artisan cheeses: Creamy pumpkin goat cheese + pumpkin spice Wensleydale
    • Perfect fall pairing: Pumpkin spice crackers (Sub: Effie's Oat Cakes) and rich, velvety DLM Pumpkin Butter
    • Easy entertaining: Everything you need for a festive fall cheese board
    • A delicious seasonal gift: Perfect for hosts, cheese lovers, Thanksgiving gatherings, and autumn celebrations
    • GP Pumpkin Everything candle while supplies last!


    What's Inside

    Mackenzie Creamery Pumpkin Goat Cheese
    Creamy artisan goat cheese blended with pumpkin and warming autumn spices.

    Somerdale Pumpkin Spice Wensleydale
    A distinctive Wensleydale cheese with honey, ginger, and cinnamon.

    Rustic Bakery Artisan Pumpkin Spice Crackers
    Crisp, seasonal crackers made for pairing with cheese and pumpkin-inspired spreads.

    DLM Old-Fashioned Pumpkin Butter
    Rich, velvety pumpkin butter made locally for DLM in Bucyrus, Ohio.

    Brand Spotlight: Mackenzie Creamery

    One of Ohio’s finest artisan cheesemakers, Mackenzie Creamery is known for handcrafted goat cheeses made with care in Hiram, Ohio. Their award-winning cheeses have earned a devoted following for their creamy texture, distinctive flavors, and artisan quality. For this fall pairing, their Pumpkin Goat Cheese brings together the tangy richness of goat cheese with the warm, comforting flavors of pumpkin and seasonal spice—making it a delicious match for our pumpkin spice crackers and DLM Pumpkin Butter.

    • Ohio artisan cheesemaker — Proudly crafted in Ohio
    • Award-winning goat cheese — Recognized for artisan quality and distinctive flavors
    • Creamy & flavorful — A delicious balance of tangy goat cheese and warm pumpkin spice
    • Perfect for fall — An exceptional addition to a Thanksgiving cheese board or autumn gathering
    Butter and Spreadable Cheese Boards

    Butter and Spreadable Cheese Boards

    Spread the Love

    Read full story