Herkimer New York Sharp Cheddar | Dorothy Lane Market
DLM Mail Order Online Exclusive | $5 OFF Every $50 Spent with Code HOLIDAY2026 |

A TASTE OF DLM

Search Dorothy Lane Market

Try a DLM favorite

    Herkimer New York Sharp Cheddar

    Loading image...

    Herkimer New York Sharp Cheddar

    $12.00

    About Herkimer New York Sharp Cheddar

    Crafting artisan cheeses since 1949, Herkimer Cheese is known for their excellent selection of Cheddar cheeses.

    Herkimer Sharp New York Cheddar is aged for a minimum of 12 months, giving it a creamy texture and distinct bite. We recommend pairing it with sliced apple, grapes, a double IPA, or glass of cabernet sauvignon.